Sani-Kast N. Scheringer M., Slomberg D., Labille J. Hungerbühler K. Addressing the complexity of water chemistry in environmental fate
modeling for engineered nanoparticles. Science of the Total Environment (2015) 535 (SI) 150-159.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2014.12.025
Keywords
Engineered nanoparticles; TiO2; Environmental fate modeling; Environmental variability; Nanoparticle fate assessment; River systems
Highlights
• New method to analyze spatial variability in engineered nanoparticle fate models
• Application to titanium dioxide nanoparticles (NPs) in the Rhône River, France
• Heteroaggregation of NPs with suspended particles reflects water chemistry
• Complexity of a wide range of water chemistries reduced by cluster analysis
• The fate of NPs can be predicted when aggregation is strong near the emission source.
Abstract
Engineered nanoparticle (ENP) fate models developed to date — aimed at predicting ENP concentration in the aqueous environment — have limited applicability because they employ constant environmental conditions along the modeled system or a highly specific environmental representation; both approaches do not show the effects of spatial and/or temporal variability. To address this conceptual gap, we developed a novel modeling strategy that: 1) incorporates spatial variability in environmental conditions in an existing ENP fate model; and 2) analyzes the effect of a wide range of randomly sampled environmental conditions (representing variations in water chemistry). This approach was employed to investigate the transport of nano-TiO2 in the Lower Rhône River (France) under numerous sets of environmental conditions. The predicted spatial concentration profiles of nano-TiO2 were then grouped according to their similarity by using cluster analysis. The analysis resulted in a small number of clusters representing groups of spatial concentration profiles. All clusters show nano-TiO2 accumulation in the sediment layer, supporting results from previous studies. Analysis of the characteristic features of each cluster demonstrated a strong association between the water conditions in regions close to the ENP emission source and the cluster membership of the corresponding spatial concentration profiles. In particular, water compositions favoring heteroaggregation between the ENPs and suspended particulate matter resulted in clusters of low variability. These conditions are, therefore, reliable predictors of the eventual fate of the modeled ENPs. The conclusions from this study are also valid for ENP fate in other large river systems. Our results, therefore, shift the focus of future modeling and experimental research of ENP environmental fate to the water characteristic in regions near the expected ENP emission sources. Under conditions favoring heteroaggregation in these regions, the fate of the ENPs can be readily predicted.